I really like your costume

From Homestar Runner Wiki

"I really like your covered all in black ink costumes."

Homestar Runner often will mistake a costume that someone (including himself) is wearing for another person. This started as a gag on for Halloween and has happens on several instances outside of Halloween toons.

Appearances

• Debut:The House That Gave Sucky Treats - HOMESTAR RUNNER: Hey Strong Bad, I really like your costume. The Spanish Inquisition? That's great.
• 3 Times Halloween Funjob - HOMESTAR RUNNER: Hey, Strong Bad, I really like your El Debarge costume.
• 3 Times Halloween Funjob again- HOMESTAR RUNNER: Say, Bubs, I really like your dirty man outfit.
• 3 Times Halloween Funjob yet, again- HOMESTAR RUNNER: Hey, Coach Z, I really like your Wesley Snakes outfit.
• Most in the Graveyard - HOMESTAR RUNNER: Hey, Homestar, I really like your Carrot Top costume. {Homestar turns his head around} I'm not Carrot Top! I'm Crocodile Dundee!
• Doomy Tales of the Macabre Teaser - HOMESTAR RUNNER: Hey everybody, I really like your covered all in black ink costumes. Kinda stole my idea, though. Don't you think?
• Decemberween Short Shorts - HOMESTAR RUNNER ORNAMENT: Hey, Strong Bad, I really like your rhinestone cowboy costume.
• Email yes, wrestling - HOMESTAR RUNNER: Hey, Strong Bad. I really like your Rudy from Fat Albert costume.