Old-Timey

From Homestar Runner Wiki

1936 is era in which the Homestar cartoons allegedly originate from. They are in black and white, with grainy footage. The characters look and sound different from their modern-day counterparts, and often have different personae. The original run of the Homestar cartoons were a series of 22 second shorts each called Kick the Can.

The Homestar Runner is Mike Chapman's favourite character in the entire HSR universe. Mike thinks he's a lot smarter and aware of what’s going on than modern-day Homestar.