Talk:Thy Dungeonman II

From Homestar Runner Wiki

Revision as of 18:50, 23 July 2005

David Bowie

The David Bowie fact is fine the way it is. Stop deleting information from it. First of all, it has gone through the STUFF process, but even if it hadn't, it shouldn't be changed. Here's why:

• The introductory sentence (with "talk david bowie") is really more like an extension of the walkthrough. Just as in transcripts, it's better not to have links in this area.
• We have a long tradition of giving a sentence-or-two summary of the relevant parts of a Wikipedia article. You shouldn't have to click on the link to get a suitable explanation, especially when you would have to wade through quite a bit of information just to arrive at what we already have on our article page.
• The three subbullets address the important points in an ordered, concise, and clear manner, and then the last one ties in the subject matter to another H*R reference.

It's dot com 04:05, 23 Jul 2005 (UTC)

• "The introductory sentence (with "talk david bowie") is really more like an extension of the walkthrough. Just as in transcripts, it's better not to have links in this area."

A lot of facts have links in dialogue. Heck, the virus transcript links to the "quadratic formula".

• "We have a long tradition of giving a sentence-or-two summary of the relevant parts of a Wikipedia article. You shouldn't have to click on the link to get a suitable explanation, especially when you would have to wade through quite a bit of information just to arrive at what we already have on our article page."

Then what's the point of Wikipedia links?

• "The three subbullets address the important points in an ordered, concise, and clear manner, and then the last one ties in the subject matter to another H*R reference."

Umm, I don't think Strong Sad as Bowie/Ziggy Stardust in Halloween Fairstival is a reference to TDM2. --TROGGA! 18:50, 23 Jul 2005 (UTC)

• "The introductory sentence (with "talk david bowie") is really more like an extension of the walkthrough. Just as in transcripts, it's better not to have links in this area."

A lot of facts have links in dialogue. Heck, the virus transcript links to the "quadratic formula."

• "We have a long tradition of giving a sentence-or-two summary of the relevant parts of a Wikipedia article. You shouldn't have to click on the link to get a suitable explanation, especially when you would have to wade through quite a bit of information just to arrive at what we already have on our article page."

Then what's the point of Wikipedia links?

• "The three subbullets address the important points in an ordered, concise, and clear manner, and then the last one ties in the subject matter to another H*R reference."

Umm, I don't think Strong Sad as Bowie/Ziggy Stardust in Halloween Fairstival is a reference to TDM2. --TROGGA! 18:50, 23 Jul 2005 (UTC)