Talk:Cubeland

From Homestar Runner Wiki

the cheat would fit in well too

This place seems to be on of Strong Bad's speculations. Clever Ben

Shouldn't this be a "place Strong Bad Made Up"? -GG Crono

No. We split all those up. "Places Strong Bad Made Up" doesn't exist anymore, in the page sense. (It's still a redirect, though.) --DorianGray

This needs more info. Retromaniac 18:14, 19 June 2006 (UTC)

Also it needs more appearences. Its really not useful to anyone.--H*Bad 18:16, 19 June 2006 (UTC)

Contents 1 "Foreign" 2 This page should be a redirect to the facts. 3 Keep 4 Argument for deletion

[edit] "Foreign"

Is Cubeland really foreign? It's made up by Strong Bad, so it can't be considered "foreign", can it? -Essence of Ghost Water

[edit] This page should be a redirect to the facts.

Cubeland doesn't deserve its own page, considering it was only seen for a moment in a single e-mail. — 76.79.214.130 (Talk | contribs) 18:49, 16 March 2021 (UTC) (left unsigned)

It should probably redirect to Made-up Places instead, considering Cubeland is documented there just as thoroughly — that is to say, hardly at all. Gfdgsgxgzgdrc 19:44, 16 March 2021 (UTC)

[edit] Keep

Hello, awesome wiki users! This is MeowMeow here, and frankly, you all make some good points. But I want to point out that this feels like it deserves it's own page. This is basically the equivalent of that place Strong Bad was in during for kids and that isn't questioned, is it? Besides, there are more important things, like preventing wiki trolls. Happy editing, User:MeowMeow

That's a good comparison, since that place doesn't have its own page either. (Also, changing unneeded pages to redirects and preventing wiki trolls aren't mutually exclusive.) Gfdgsgxgzgdrc 01:33, 24 April 2023 (UTC)

You have a point, but this is the HRWIKI we're talking about here. We've had stuff way more obscure then this. But you raise a G-E-W-D GEWD point and I would love to hear more! Your friend, MeowMeow,

[edit] Argument for deletion

I don't want to seem too much like a stick in the mud, but I do think this article is completely pointless. While an argument certainly can be (and has been) made for this article staying, I feel there is nothing this article elaborates upon that hasn't already been said in Made-Up Places. There simply isn't enough information to make this article worth it. My second argument for its deletion is quite subjective, but I think it holds some weight regardless: Cubeland is a completely non-essential part of the facts. It exists as a one-off throwaway gag, and while one-off gags still deserve to get mentioned on the wiki, they don't deserve their own articles (they should be in a list or something.) Whether something is 'important' to a sbemail's topic or not matters here. The fictional space shown in for kids was essential to the sbemail, laying down the entire foundation of why Strong Bad shouldn't have a kids show; thus important to the cartoon and warranting a spot in the "dedicated acknowledgement" pile (albeit in the form of Whaddaya Know, Haddi-Man? which takes place in the same fictional space). This same argument has been successfully made for the existence of the page Super Mud, and I think that same argument can be made against this article. This is just something to think about; I'll still be able to sleep whether or not this article stays up. Maybe. --Mizzomi 01:19, 25 March 2024 (UTC)

There are plenty of one-off gags with their own articles, but only when they can't fit onto another page (there is no list that could contain Hamburger Shampoo or C'mon! It's FOG! for example). The same can't be said for this page, and since most of the talk page seems to agree as well, I'm going to go ahead and redirect it. Gfdgsgxgzgdrc 21:58, 29 March 2024 (UTC)