From Homestar Runner Wiki
Occasionally, characters will be seen wearing an eyepatch, usually for no apparent reason.
- Meet Marshie — "Pinner" is a plate of marshmallows wearing a bowler hat, a cigar, and an eyepatch.
- Email island — Pinner makes another appearance.
- Teen Girl Squad Issue 4 — Arrow'd Guy rides on a brain with an eyepatch.
- The Blue Laser Commander always wears an eyepatch, as do the Blue Laser Babies.
- Thy Dungeonman 3 — One of the possibilities for Kigalonian in the tavern across the street is an eyepatch.
- Email more armies — The On Point Kings all wear eyepatches.
- Teen Girl Squad Issue 14 — Cheerlubber wears an eyepatch.
- Email hiding (Easter egg) — Scar is wearing an eyepatch.
- Homestar Ruiner — Marzipan's flashback to a party includes Strong Bad wearing an eyepatch.
- Strong Badia the Free — One of the hidden costume items is a sugar-frosted eyepatch.