From Homestar Runner Wiki
Trophies appear frequently in Free Country, USA and are often given as prizes in contests. The Cheat appears to have a particular fixation on trophies and has been occasionally awarded "pizza trophies".
- Original Book — Homestar Runner and Pom Pom share the Strongest Man in the World trophy.
- The Reddest Radish — Marzipan wins the Reddest Radish trophy.
- A Jumping Jack Contest — Homestar Runner and Strong Bad (trying to pose as Pom Pom) share the "What a Great Prize This Is" trophy.
- Where's The Cheat? — The Cheat's cigarettes are "Trophy Lights".
- Chinese Food Toons Menu — This has a trophy watermark for A Jumping Jack Contest.
- Email crazy cartoon — In The Cheat's cartoon, he receives trophies from Strong Bad (twice), Homestar Runner and Coach Z. After the cartoon is over, Strong Bad says that while he didn't think it deserved a trophy, or even a pizza, it might merit a pizza trophy.
- Awexome Cross — If you beat all seven levels, The Cheat wins a pizza trophy.
- Email kids' book — Strong Bad changes "shared the trophy" in the Original Book to "lifted a comode" (Easter egg Strumstar Hammer).
- New Boots — Strong Bad says that, with a little extra effort, he might have given The Cheat "a trophy full of Steak-umms".
- Peasant's Quest — You can receive the message "Yeah. You smote the Kerrek. You deserve a trophy full of Mutton-ums" (a reference to the aforementioned Steak-umms).
- The Li'l Brudder Show — Li'l Brudder pops out of a "Just One" trophy.
- No Hands On Deck! — Coach Z holds up four Tony Awards.
- Strongest Man in the World — Pom Pom wins the Golbol trophy.
- Email pet show — Homestar (entered by Marzipan) wins a trophy for the Cat Mess Inbredtational Pet Show.
- Jibblies 2 — In an Easter Egg, Pom Pom throws a golbol at Homestar.
- Homestar Ruiner — A silver trophy is awarded to the winner of Tri-Annual Race to the End of the Race, and other trophies are won for doing other achievements throughout the game.
- Trudgemank — The Cheat gives himself another pizza trophy.
- 8-Bit is Enough — An 8-Bit golden trophy is stolen by Strong Bad, and soon rewarded to Putchnya Shotski.