| Image | Description | Appearances
|
 | The Homestar Runner
- See main article: The Homestar Runner (storybook)
This version of Homestar talks in his old voice and usually wears a duckie shirt.
| Complete Filmography
|
 | Tiny-Handed Strong Bad
- See main article: Tiny-Handed Strong Bad
Unlike the exaggerated voice Strong Bad talked with in the early Flash toons, this version of Strong Bad talks in a bland, monotonous voice. He has no diamond and has white eyes, unlike modern-day Strong Bad's green eyes and diamond.
| Complete Filmography
|
 | Storybook The Cheat
This version of The Cheat is much lighter colored and more slug-like. He has smaller spots and more hairs at the back of his head.
| Original Book, flashback, Main Page 20, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser
|
 | Storybook Strong Mad
Strong Mad's head bumps up a little bit more in this version.
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, alternate universe, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods
|
 | Storybook Strong Sad
This version of Strong Sad has shorter arms and an additional toe on each of his Soolnds.
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, Main Page 20, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods
|
 | Storybook Pom Pom
Pom Pom's legs are much pointier in this version. He has smaller eyes.
| Original Book, flashback, alternate universe, Strongest Man in the World, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods
|
 | Storybook Marzipan
Storybook Marzipan has a visible tongue and white eyes. She also has no decoration at the bottom of her dress.
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, alternate universe, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser
|
 | Storybook Coach Zee
Storybook Coach Z is a paler green and the colors on his hat are switched. There is no shine on his medallion and the Z has a point up at the end.
| Where My Hat is At?, flashback, alternate universe, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser
|
 | Storybook Bubs
This version has a rounder head, and his bigger eye has no blue in it.
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, origins, alternate universe, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser
|
 | The Prince of Town
- See main article: The Prince of Town
He is much taller and skinnier than the modern-day king. He wears a feathered cap instead of a crown.
| flashback, Main Page 20, Fan Costumes '09, @StrongBadActual, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser
|
 | Storybook The Poopsmith
He was first seen in silhouette form. He has a full head of curly blond hair and a more athletic, hunched-over body. He also has shorter fingers, no whatsit on his gloves, and more distinct feet.
| The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods Teaser, The Homestar Runner Enters the Spooky Woods
|
 | Storybook The Announcer
He has no shine on his monocle, and he has some blue on his suit. His neck is black.
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, Strongest Man in the World, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
 | Storybook The Grape Fairie
He has no stubble on his face when he talks.
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, Strongest Man in the World, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
 | Storybook The Fat Bee
He has no curl at the end of his tail.
| Original Book, Old Flash Stuff, Main Page 20, alternate universe, Weekly Fanstuff (Aug 3 2006), Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
 | Storybook Mr. Bland
Storybook Mr. Bland is very similar to his modern-day variation.
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, flashback, origins, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
 | Storybook Señor
Storybook Señor is very similar to modern-day.
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, flashback, Main Page 20, origins, Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
 | Storybook The Robot
It is much less detailed than its modern version.
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer
|
 | Storybook The Umpire
His colors are darker, his arms are slightly thinner, and his shoes are smaller and less curvy.
| Where My Hat is At?
|
 | Storybook Dijjery Doo
His arms are simpler, his tusks are bigger, and his head is more oddly shaped.
| Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
 | Storybook The Sneak
He uses the same model as The Sneak's Old-Timey self but without the shading and his hair sticks up less.
He is the first variation of an already existing variation, The Sneak being The Cheat's Old-Timey Counterpart.
| Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
 | Storybook Strong Glad
Due to the original version only being a sketch, this version is colored, with darker, more refined lines, and a bigger body.
| Homestar Runner Goes For the Gold
|
