| Image | Description | Appearances
|
 | The Homestar Runner
- See main article: The Homestar Runner (storybook)
This version of Homestar talks in his old voice and usually wears a duckie shirt.
| Original Book, Where My Hat is At?, Strumstar Hammer, flashback, Main Page 20, alternate universe, Strongest Man in the World, Homestar Gets Something Stuck in His Craw, Where My Hat is At? (toon), Halloween Safety, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Tiny-Handed Strong Bad
- See main article: Tiny-Handed Strong Bad
Unlike the exaggerated voice Strong Bad talked with in the early Flash toons, this version of Strong Bad talks in a bland, monotonous voice. He has no diamond and has white eyes, unlike modern-day Strong Bad's green eyes and diamond.
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, flashback, Main Page 20, rock opera (voice only), alternate universe, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, Halloween Safety, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook The Cheat
This version of The Cheat is much lighter colored and more slug-like. He has smaller spots and more hairs at the back of his head.
| Original Book, flashback, Main Page 20, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook Strong Mad
Strong Mad's head bumps up a little bit more in this version.
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, alternate universe, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook Strong Sad
This version of Strong Sad has shorter arms.
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, Main Page 20, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook Pom Pom
Pom Pom's legs are much pointier in this version. He has smaller eyes.
| Original Book, flashback, alternate universe, Strongest Man in the World, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook Marzipan
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, alternate universe, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook Coach Zee
Storybook Coach Z is a paler green and the colors on his hat are switched. There is no shine on his medallion and the Z has a point up at the end.
| Where My Hat is At?, flashback, alternate universe, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook Bubs
| Sketchbook (museum), flashback, origins, alternate universe, The Homestar Runner Gets Something Stuck In His Craw, @StrongBadActual
|
 | The Prince of Town
- See main article: The Prince of Town
He is much taller and skinnier than the modern-day king. He wears a feathered cap instead of a crown. He is the only storybook character that wasn't introduced before his modern-day version.
| flashback, Main Page 20, Fan Costumes '09, @StrongBadActual
|
 | Storybook The Announcer
He has no shine on his monocle, and he has some blue on his suit. His neck is black.
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, Strongest Man in the World
|
 | Storybook The Grape Fairie
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, Strongest Man in the World
|
 | Storybook The Fat Bee
He has no curl at the end of his tail.
| Original Book, Old Flash Stuff, Main Page 20, alternate universe, Weekly Fanstuff — August 3, 2006
|
 | Storybook Mr. Bland
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, flashback, origins
|
 | Storybook Señor
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer, flashback, Main Page 20, origins
|
 | Storybook The Robot
| Original Book, Strumstar Hammer
|
 | Storybook The Umpire
| Where My Hat is At?
|
